+- Accountancy Forum (https://www.accountancy.com.pk/forum)
+-- Forum: General (https://www.accountancy.com.pk/forum/forum-general)
+--- Forum: General Discussion (https://www.accountancy.com.pk/forum/forum-general-discussion)
+--- Thread: ACMA VS ACCA (/thread-acma-vs-acca--4780)
- Schuaeb - 10-04-2007
Pracs I guess and hope that things on this thread do not progress the way you perceived.
- Pracs - 10-04-2007
<blockquote id="quote"><font size="1" face="Verdana, Tahoma, Arial" id="quote">quote<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"><i>Originally posted by Schuaeb</i>
<br />Pracs I guess and hope that things on this thread do not progress the way you perceived.
<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"></font id="quote"></blockquote id="quote">
Why do you say, where is your sense of humour !
- Schuaeb - 10-05-2007
There was some sense of humour involved in my post you referred. So now may I ask where is your sense of humour
- shsaeed - 10-05-2007
I think here we are discussing ACMA VS ACCA not the
sense of humour.
Muhammad Asim Saeed
- kamranACA - 10-05-2007
Dears,
Should we discuss more on this issue?
I think it is enough which has been discussed. Shoaib, to your queries I reply as under
ACMA (ICMAP) cannot be compared to CA as
- it does not have an articles experience under the feeling of a bound registered contract; (this feeling has lots of meaning. any internship with own free will cannot replace it).
- efforts required to qualify ACMA are far lesser than CA, in my view.
- ACMAs normally appear to have two problems, at one hand they feel they are qualified. This helps elevating their heads on the shoulders. On the other hand they normally dont know too much about what practically happens when some one is on job. This makes them to feel some deficiencies. This situation does not let them to create acceptability for learning from those who have such knowledge.
- Go to some seminar of ICMAP in Pakistan. You will see a particular community who has done ACMA while they were in government jobs (even as clerks). Such community can be seen every where. I mean in all cities of Pakistan. They can never make their minds like a professional although have qualified professionally playing this exam game all of their lives.
- ACMA as a community are not stronger enough to support well their own profession and juniors.
- What I have observed, ACMAs normally are less desirious to learn (when in jobs) and more desirious to show theirselves as DOCTORS OF PHILOSPHY. This never helps them.
- ACMAs are least taken in industry on KEY POSTS and therefore go to public sector / govt jobs. Due to this they cannot get out of the culture of that in-efficient, primarily dishonest public sector and its other ugly attributes.
These are a few points and are not aimed at to break the hearts. Rather, these are realities. Just check them out with patience and cool head.
I dont much know about UK's ACMA.
Regards,
Kamran.
- Schuaeb - 10-06-2007
Infact I never compared ACMA with CA, and why should I. I just posted my views that why by some people prefrences is given to ACMA over CA.
I can't comment that whether ACMAs are desirious to work or not, however, the second thing told by you about them has also been found true by me.
I found your post conforming my views about ACMA. My little analysis concluded that ACMA is not a very advisable thing to do as the effort you put to qualify is not justfully rewarded and that is exactly what you said.
- Schuaeb - 10-11-2007
Waiting for your valuable comments Kamran
- kamranACA - 10-11-2007
Yes, you are right Shaoib,
I personally dont find it a good option.
However, CIMA of UK is a good emerging avenue.
Regards,
Kamran.
- sajid naveed khan - 10-22-2007
Dears i wld like to get get another information about expenses of ACMA and ACCA, CIMA of uk
- Astute Accountant - 10-28-2007
CIMA FEES are
Registration fee GBP 54
Annual Subscription for Students GBP 84
Certificate in Business Accounting GBP 45
Managerial Level GBP 59
Strategic Level GBP 64
TOPCIMA GBP 85
Annual Subscription for members are round about GBP 200 per year.
- sajid naveed khan - 10-29-2007
Thanks but me waiting for more
- Astute Accountant - 10-31-2007
Please ask Amir, He can let you know the Charges of ACCA.
I can't recall the Fees per module or per paper of ACMA of PAKISTAN but it does cost round about Rs. 50,000 for the whole course.
- sajid naveed khan - 10-31-2007
Thanx Accountat
- Astute Accountant - 11-05-2007
Please note The fees mentioned for each level of CIMA are the fees per paper and not for the entire level.
- sajid naveed khan - 11-22-2007
What is the percentage of qualified ACCA's,ACMA's