CA after ACCA - Printable Version

CA after ACCA - Printable Version

+- Accountancy Forum (https://www.accountancy.com.pk/forum)
+-- Forum: The Profession (https://www.accountancy.com.pk/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Students (https://www.accountancy.com.pk/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=13)
+--- Thread: CA after ACCA (/showthread.php?tid=1643)

Pages: 1 2

CA after ACCA - logicalbanda - 01-31-2005

ASALAM O ALAIKUM
can we do CA after ACCA and pls can any one tell me what is the procedure to do so
that how much exemptions will be offered in CA after doing ACCA
AND IF WE DO CA AFTER ACCA IS IT NOT BETTER THAN DOING SIMPLE CA ONLY
pls guide me if u can

ALLAH HAFIZ

Edited by - logicalbanda on Jan 31 2005 124734 AM

- bilal azhar - 01-31-2005

yes u can do ca after acca.full ca inter(upto module D) is exempt to ACCA passed students.And the reason why people want to do ca only after acca is that ca is by far more difficult as compare to acca.so after passing acca not only u get a degree but also exemption from ca inter.

By the way i think that exemption available to acca passed students from ca inter is totally unfair.although acca students study a lots of different subjects at advanced level,but surely ca inter is more difficult than acca.

bilal

- maani - 01-31-2005

Its good idea to do CA after ACCA...but still impossible in Pakistan...
I know 3 persons who complete CA inter...then do ACCA along with final examinations of CA...
but i dont know any person who have completed ACCA first and then completed his CA...Do anybuddy know such person?
its easy to talk about this stream...but its a tough task...

Ace

- logicalbanda - 02-01-2005

<BLOCKQUOTE id=quote>quote<hr height=1 noshade id=quote>
ASALAM O ALAIKUM
can we do CA after ACCA and pls can any one tell me what is the procedure to do so
that how much exemptions will be offered in CA after doing ACCA
AND IF WE DO CA AFTER ACCA IS IT NOT BETTER THAN DOING SIMPLE CA ONLY
pls guide me if u can

but if we do ca after acca do we have the same value as a normal ca
ALLAH HAFIZ

Edited by - logicalbanda on Jan 31 2005 124734 AM
<hr height=1 noshade id=quote></BLOCKQUOTE id=quote>

- AvgJoe - 02-01-2005

Dear Logical,

I dont think that a person who does CA after ACCA is treated differently than a person who does only CA (ICAP). The procedure for doing ACCA & than CA would be as follows (in ur specific case) -

1) Give CAT (1 yr, Its like a entry test for ACCA)
2) Give Part 2 & 3 Acca Papers (2 years, These are main ACCA papers.)
3) After passing, get exemptions from ICAP for Mod (A-D).
4) You will than have to do training for 3 years & during this time, u will be eligible to pass Mod E & F (ICAP) Papers.
5) Upon completion of all ICAP papers & ur training, u will be a CA & ACCA.

Cheeers,
AvgJoe

- AvgJoe - 02-01-2005

<BLOCKQUOTE id=quote>quote<hr height=1 noshade id=quote>
By the way i think that exemption available to acca passed students from ca inter is totally unfair.although acca students study a lots of different subjects at advanced level,but surely ca inter is more difficult than acca.

bilal
<hr height=1 noshade id=quote></BLOCKQUOTE id=quote>

Hmm...interesting statement. Guys, how about having a CONSTRUCTIVE debate on this? I think we should first compare the syllabi (syllabus-es) & methodologies of ACCA & CA (Inter) before passing a verdict like this. I know, we have already debated too many times on ACCA vs CA, but we havent done an ACCA vs CA (Inter) analysis yet.
So how abt it? I m posting a seperate thread for this, so if any of u guys wanna contribute plz post there.

<BLOCKQUOTE id=quote>quote<hr height=1 noshade id=quote>
maani Its good idea to do CA after ACCA...but still impossible in Pakistan...
I know 3 persons who complete CA inter...then do ACCA along with final examinations of CA...
but i dont know any person who have completed ACCA first and then completed his CA...Do anybuddy know such person?
its easy to talk about this stream...but its a tough task...

Ace

<hr height=1 noshade id=quote></BLOCKQUOTE id=quote>

Maani yaar, why do u think its impossible? Any specific reasons ? Plz share them with us.

- bilal azhar - 02-01-2005

INStead of comparing the syllubus we should compare the exam papers and its structure.There is not a huge difference in syllubus.in fact acca syllubus is more logical and conceptual than ca inter but the difference lies in paper levels.
ICaps paper is far far more difficult than acca paper plus there is no choice and surety that one question will be out of the syllubus in almost every paper.

bilal

- logicalbanda - 02-01-2005

<BLOCKQUOTE id=quote>quote<hr height=1 noshade id=quote>
Dear Logical,

I dont think that a person who does CA after ACCA is treated differently than a person who does only CA (ICAP). The procedure for doing ACCA & than CA would be as follows (in ur specific case) -

1) Give CAT (1 yr, Its like a entry test for ACCA)
2) Give Part 2 & 3 Acca Papers (2 years, These are main ACCA papers.)
3) After passing, get exemptions from ICAP for Mod (A-D).
4) You will than have to do training for 3 years & during this time, u will be eligible to pass Mod E & F (ICAP) Papers.
5) Upon completion of all ICAP papers & ur training, u will be a CA & ACCA.

Cheeers,
AvgJoe

<hr height=1 noshade id=quote></BLOCKQUOTE id=quote>

thanks for your valuable ideas and suggestions but now pls tell me what is better
1-doing CA AFTER ACCA OR
2-DOING SIMPLY CA FROM ICAP

ALLAH HAFIZ

- maani - 02-03-2005

Hi Avgoe,
I said its still impossible...I didn't said it will remain impossible...any ambitious person like you can make it possible...

Ace

- syedhassan - 02-05-2005

<blockquote id="quote">quote<hr height="1" noshade id="quote">Originally posted by maani
 Its good idea to do CA after ACCA...but still impossible in Pakistan...
I know 3 persons who complete CA inter...then do ACCA along with final examinations of CA...
but i dont know any person who have completed ACCA first and then completed his CA...Do anybuddy know such person?
its easy to talk about this stream...but its a tough task...

Ace
<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"></blockquote id="quote">
hi there.. maani...
sure ur right, as i have a friend, doing ACCA after E-Module
as he he's stuck for 8 years... done articles for 2years but atill there...
so, "THIS IS THE REASOn WHY PEOPLE GO TO ACCA FIRST..."
and exemption for CA's in ACCA are till 2.1...(is this fair??)
i dont think so, its should be more...
but its so, due to the arraingment of IAS's and FRS's and other in ACCA, which is much well organized than CA's....
and i have see many ACCA,CA's in Pakistan...
much of them are even young
so its verry.. very much possible..
cheers...
syedhassan.

- turithegreat - 03-05-2005

<blockquote id="quote">quote<hr height="1" noshade id="quote">Originally posted by logicalbanda
 ASALAM O ALAIKUM
can we do CA after ACCA and pls can any one tell me what is the procedure to do so
that how much exemptions will be offered in CA after doing ACCA
AND IF WE DO CA AFTER ACCA IS IT NOT BETTER THAN DOING SIMPLE CA ONLY
pls guide me if u can

ALLAH HAFIZ

Edited by - logicalbanda on Jan 31 2005 124734 AM
<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"></blockquote id="quote">

- shahzad - 03-12-2005

main too yahee best samajhta hoon kay agar koeee ca hee karna chahta hay too direct ca main entry lay, acca kar kay ca karnaa kafee tough banay gaaa

shahzad

- Deimos - 01-08-2009

salams
plz can anyone tell me that if we want to do ca after acca then do we also have to do the internship of acca.plz tell me about this

- rabia-k - 01-08-2009

<blockquote id="quote">quote<hr height="1" noshade id="quote">Originally posted by Deimos
 salams
plz can anyone tell me that if we want to do ca after acca then do we also have to do the internship of acca.plz tell me about this
<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"></blockquote id="quote">

hi ...which CA are u talking about??? in case of ICAEW if u r an ACCA affiliate u can get exemptions from 13 or 14 papers.. i think u will only have to give 3 or 4 exams of ICAEW... but to sit for the last 2 exams and a busienss case study u will need to have completed 2 yrs of training..please check the ICAEW website for exemptions available to ACCA students

please check the following link for exemptions available for ACCA students

http//www.icaew.com/index.cfm/route/146395/fuseaction/profAward/icaew_ga/en/Students/Credit_for_prior_learning_directory

- Deimos - 01-10-2009

thnx for ur reply well actually i'm talking about ICAP the exemption given to acca students for ICAP is from module A-D then one only has to give module E n F
and to apply for apply for module E n F do we have to do the internship of acca also?
plz help