Abb ACCA k Bad log CA ko monh Nahien Lagaengae.

[Muhammad Amir]

Dear Mr KamranACA,

I was anticipating your disagreement with me on point 5, 8 and 9.

For point 5 i do not need to say anything, as this is the reality that everyone can see.

For point 8 i will say that past papers of ACCA and ICAP are available in their websites if you have some time then you can visit those urls, download past papers and analyse the difference. This is something observed by me recently, i did winter(December) 2006 question on Consolidation(GIF,JPG,BMP on piecemeal acquisition and disposal of an entity) of module 'E' and i was shocked by the level of this paper.

Similarly when i was in F9 in last attempt i have done most of the past papers of BFD and found nothing more than what we learned in class except some topics like risk management especially interest rate risk, which was having some more complexity as compared to F9's risk management.

Past Papers of both bodies are available on.

http//www.icap.org.pk/Examination/PAST_PPR.htm

http//www.accaglobal.com/students/study_exams/qualifications/acca_choose/acca/

I hope your disagreement on point 8 has been diluted.

Regards,

Muhammad Amir