07-23-2008, 05:58 PM
Dear Amir,
I don't doubt that you may have some more knowledge about Javed Iqbal. However, I wonder if you claim to have more knowledge of a father than his son in the particular context of Iqbal and Javed Iqbal.
I have also some time earlier tried to clarify you that majority of Pakistan's founders wished it to be a secular country. A mullah cannot accept it because the existence and exploration of this fact leads to curtailment of his bread and butter which he has to earn by always creating conflicting religious issues. I again mention that the term mullah is very specific and must not be mistaken to again raise new foolish allegations and arguments. Still I feel, we should not go into a long debate on this issue becoz it is not co-inciding with the subject matter.
You quoted following words of my previous e-mail
"he carried the character of a common man"
and
"I know so many of us believe him a Waliallah which he was not probably."
Is there any doubt on above statements? What you want to highlight? I could not apprehend the cultivation of your mind by making such quotation. Yes, in my view, Allama Iqbal carried character of a common man. What do you feel contrary to this statement? Do you feel every common man is a bad creature? In my view, he is not Waliallah. Do you feel that every man who is not waliallah is a bad creature? I at my own accepted that so many of us believe him Waliallah. What you want to find out? Was he a Waliallah in your opinion? If yes I have already said so manys believe so. What is new in your analysis? Can you please explain? I don't try to become over smart as you have requested. Now its your turn. Become over smart and explain your view point.
Whatever you wrote about the female's education may not be wrong theoratically but whatever actions your fellows have taken and intend to take are not in line with their words. Further, if Pakistan's conditions are not correct then start correcting it from our ownselves (I mean indviduals). It has no fault of females in fact. I wonder how we can suggest to impose restrition on females due to the fault of males. Bad condition rests with men and restriction is to be imposed on women. ) It's quite a strange mentality which does not match the words.
I in fact dont throw mud on any one. Mud may be exisiting in the air and some peoples have developed bad allergy conditions against such mud. I recommend such persons to get treatment and I pray for their earlier cure and recovery. )
Yes, I will try to give you reference of some Hadees book (out of seven) whenever I will manage to visit some library. It's a promise.
Thank you for taking out time to reply my posts.
Regards,
KAMRAN.
I don't doubt that you may have some more knowledge about Javed Iqbal. However, I wonder if you claim to have more knowledge of a father than his son in the particular context of Iqbal and Javed Iqbal.
I have also some time earlier tried to clarify you that majority of Pakistan's founders wished it to be a secular country. A mullah cannot accept it because the existence and exploration of this fact leads to curtailment of his bread and butter which he has to earn by always creating conflicting religious issues. I again mention that the term mullah is very specific and must not be mistaken to again raise new foolish allegations and arguments. Still I feel, we should not go into a long debate on this issue becoz it is not co-inciding with the subject matter.
You quoted following words of my previous e-mail
"he carried the character of a common man"
and
"I know so many of us believe him a Waliallah which he was not probably."
Is there any doubt on above statements? What you want to highlight? I could not apprehend the cultivation of your mind by making such quotation. Yes, in my view, Allama Iqbal carried character of a common man. What do you feel contrary to this statement? Do you feel every common man is a bad creature? In my view, he is not Waliallah. Do you feel that every man who is not waliallah is a bad creature? I at my own accepted that so many of us believe him Waliallah. What you want to find out? Was he a Waliallah in your opinion? If yes I have already said so manys believe so. What is new in your analysis? Can you please explain? I don't try to become over smart as you have requested. Now its your turn. Become over smart and explain your view point.
Whatever you wrote about the female's education may not be wrong theoratically but whatever actions your fellows have taken and intend to take are not in line with their words. Further, if Pakistan's conditions are not correct then start correcting it from our ownselves (I mean indviduals). It has no fault of females in fact. I wonder how we can suggest to impose restrition on females due to the fault of males. Bad condition rests with men and restriction is to be imposed on women. ) It's quite a strange mentality which does not match the words.
I in fact dont throw mud on any one. Mud may be exisiting in the air and some peoples have developed bad allergy conditions against such mud. I recommend such persons to get treatment and I pray for their earlier cure and recovery. )
Yes, I will try to give you reference of some Hadees book (out of seven) whenever I will manage to visit some library. It's a promise.
Thank you for taking out time to reply my posts.
Regards,
KAMRAN.