09-13-2004, 08:34 AM
YOUR COMMENT
"salam
well aik bari ajeb si guftugo ko sunnay ka ittifaq hoa k interest haram hay k halal
bari mazrat k sath kuch log muhatram alamas ko maulana aur mulla kah kar un ka mazaq uranay ki koshish bhi kartay hoy pay gay.
janab ap sab say aik sawal mujhay ya bata day k ap may say kitno nay quran tafser aur tarjumay say parha hoa hay kitno ko bhukari sharif ati hay."
MY ANSWER
Walaikum assalaam terry_batman
first of all Maulana/Mullah is not a SWEAR word, secondly nobody is trying to make fun of them instead many of them act in a way where we should not only question but also rectify them then and there.
we all respect learned Ulma-e-din and are opposed to them who create confusion in the minds of layman. it is not their fault....infact it is our fault because we want an EASY WAY OUT by saying unless we have read and memorised Quran and Bukhari sharif we cannot question anyone. Allhumdulillah i have read Quran with translation and where-ever needed refered to other books for detailed explanation. it doesnot make me un-questionable though and it is not necessary that whatever i say is correct.
YOUR COMMENT
"apna professional paper jo aik insan ka banaya hoa hay bagair teacher ki madad say hota nahi islam ko jo Allah pak ka deen hay bagair kisi alim k samaghnay chalay hian.
janab sachi bat to ya hay k .
zina bara gunah hay.
jhoot bara gunah hay
geebat bara gunah hay
walaydain ki nafarmani bara gunah hay
chori bara gunah hay"
MY ANSWER
Who told u that u cannot understand Quran unless you have learned all the Islamic books......and who told you that all Maulanas know everything and whatever they say is correct. Why dont you beleive in Maulanas who belong to the other sect for eg if you are a Sunni why dont you believe in a Shia Maulana or if you belong to Barelwi Maslak why dont you believe in Deo-bundi Maulana......AFTERALL THEY ARE ALL ULMA-E-DEEN and have definitley read Quran and MEMORISED Sahi-Bukhari.
i bet if u start reading Quran and its translation you won't find it as difficult as many PEOPLE say it is. i believe being brought up in Pakistan we all have the pre-requisite knowledge to understand the background....and whenever u are not sure u can always refer to other books and ofcource learned Maulanas.
my friend YOU will be answerable to your own deeds and nobody else. we cant just blindly follow whatever maulanas say. we have to look at the basis and reasoning of it and ask for Allah's help to guide us. we should be clear in our intentions that we want to understand the TRUTH.
as far as RIBA is concerned i would like to know YOUR point of view. u said SOOD is haram because Quran says it is haram. can i ask u to define Sood? or differentiate b/w Sood and Riba?
we are not saying that Riba is Halal - we are just trying to work out what it is? is it really what Quran has explicitly prohibited or is it something else...........
i hope my comments will make my point very clear to u, we have nothing against any maulana and ofcource none of us can afford to challenge the ultimate guide Quran.
Kind Regards
Azeem
"salam
well aik bari ajeb si guftugo ko sunnay ka ittifaq hoa k interest haram hay k halal
bari mazrat k sath kuch log muhatram alamas ko maulana aur mulla kah kar un ka mazaq uranay ki koshish bhi kartay hoy pay gay.
janab ap sab say aik sawal mujhay ya bata day k ap may say kitno nay quran tafser aur tarjumay say parha hoa hay kitno ko bhukari sharif ati hay."
MY ANSWER
Walaikum assalaam terry_batman
first of all Maulana/Mullah is not a SWEAR word, secondly nobody is trying to make fun of them instead many of them act in a way where we should not only question but also rectify them then and there.
we all respect learned Ulma-e-din and are opposed to them who create confusion in the minds of layman. it is not their fault....infact it is our fault because we want an EASY WAY OUT by saying unless we have read and memorised Quran and Bukhari sharif we cannot question anyone. Allhumdulillah i have read Quran with translation and where-ever needed refered to other books for detailed explanation. it doesnot make me un-questionable though and it is not necessary that whatever i say is correct.
YOUR COMMENT
"apna professional paper jo aik insan ka banaya hoa hay bagair teacher ki madad say hota nahi islam ko jo Allah pak ka deen hay bagair kisi alim k samaghnay chalay hian.
janab sachi bat to ya hay k .
zina bara gunah hay.
jhoot bara gunah hay
geebat bara gunah hay
walaydain ki nafarmani bara gunah hay
chori bara gunah hay"
MY ANSWER
Who told u that u cannot understand Quran unless you have learned all the Islamic books......and who told you that all Maulanas know everything and whatever they say is correct. Why dont you beleive in Maulanas who belong to the other sect for eg if you are a Sunni why dont you believe in a Shia Maulana or if you belong to Barelwi Maslak why dont you believe in Deo-bundi Maulana......AFTERALL THEY ARE ALL ULMA-E-DEEN and have definitley read Quran and MEMORISED Sahi-Bukhari.
i bet if u start reading Quran and its translation you won't find it as difficult as many PEOPLE say it is. i believe being brought up in Pakistan we all have the pre-requisite knowledge to understand the background....and whenever u are not sure u can always refer to other books and ofcource learned Maulanas.
my friend YOU will be answerable to your own deeds and nobody else. we cant just blindly follow whatever maulanas say. we have to look at the basis and reasoning of it and ask for Allah's help to guide us. we should be clear in our intentions that we want to understand the TRUTH.
as far as RIBA is concerned i would like to know YOUR point of view. u said SOOD is haram because Quran says it is haram. can i ask u to define Sood? or differentiate b/w Sood and Riba?
we are not saying that Riba is Halal - we are just trying to work out what it is? is it really what Quran has explicitly prohibited or is it something else...........
i hope my comments will make my point very clear to u, we have nothing against any maulana and ofcource none of us can afford to challenge the ultimate guide Quran.
Kind Regards
Azeem