07-26-2008, 12:36 AM
Kamran, has been quite appropriate in saying that Amir's posts are devoid of logic and as I read them on an ongoing basis,these are a source of amusement and at the same time of concern, for I fear more and more of our youth are falling into this trap and propoganda.
Amir, I would suggest you do some research on the ideology and history of Pakistan. You also need to understand what the difference is between an Islamic (I don't believe we as a Muslim nation have been or presently are in a condition of creating an Islamic state, the only exceptions were Khulfae Rashedeen)Iqbal, Jinnah and all others were working for a Muslim state, read the original texts of their speeches (mostly in English)and not doctored versions in URDU for a better understanding. The word 'Islam' has been used as to identify the relegion of Muslims and not as the Caliphate or Islamic emirate that you are dreaming of. The objectives Resolution, that was passed on added to our first set of constitutions and the many thereafter was done so after Jinnah and Liaqat Ali Khan. All our relegious parties joined the bandwagon half heartidly on to Pakistan, when there was no choice of staying in a United India!! They have been behind this propoganda and thanks to Zia ul Haq's era.
I would be interested in other people's view on this. Amir before you attempt to reply to this, please understand it is possible to be a good practising muslim living within a muslim majority, even if a secular state. That is how a billion plus muslims live today (and have been for 1400 years).
Amir, I would suggest you do some research on the ideology and history of Pakistan. You also need to understand what the difference is between an Islamic (I don't believe we as a Muslim nation have been or presently are in a condition of creating an Islamic state, the only exceptions were Khulfae Rashedeen)Iqbal, Jinnah and all others were working for a Muslim state, read the original texts of their speeches (mostly in English)and not doctored versions in URDU for a better understanding. The word 'Islam' has been used as to identify the relegion of Muslims and not as the Caliphate or Islamic emirate that you are dreaming of. The objectives Resolution, that was passed on added to our first set of constitutions and the many thereafter was done so after Jinnah and Liaqat Ali Khan. All our relegious parties joined the bandwagon half heartidly on to Pakistan, when there was no choice of staying in a United India!! They have been behind this propoganda and thanks to Zia ul Haq's era.
I would be interested in other people's view on this. Amir before you attempt to reply to this, please understand it is possible to be a good practising muslim living within a muslim majority, even if a secular state. That is how a billion plus muslims live today (and have been for 1400 years).
