08-19-2010, 08:13 AM
Smarza said "...as the matter of the fake degree is concerned, that can only be associated with the crieteria to become MNA, not with the Islamic Scholar, Take the Example of Molana Modoodi, Molana Yousuf Ludyaanvi etc. Have they got any PhD. Degree from anywhere?"
Reply Mr. SMarza, Maulana Modoodi OR Molana Yousuf Ludhiyanvi did not have any degree to become islamic scholor, because it is really not a criteria to have a degree to become a great scholor or scientist and there are many such examples, very much true.
However,
Had Maulana Modoodi OR Yousuf Ludhiyanvi bought a fake degree to bost themselves as Great Islamic Scholors then 1. They were regarded as people with fraud and fake minds/nature. However they never did so i mean they never did fake things in their lives as like Aamir Liaquat Hussain.
2. If it is proved that Amir Liaquat has bought such fake degrees to get himself regarded as a doctor/scholor of islam then according to your definition, if he was really experienced he never needed to do all such cheap and indecent things to fool people with fraud. Therefore, it also reveals his approach which is in contradiction to the criteria set by you Mr. SMarza.
3. His Islamic experience All his programs are based on the problems related to Tareeqat (Methodology) which is a branch of islamic studies. The actual problems faced by islamic ummah are not critical to Methodology (How to do How to offer Prayers, How much pay zakat etc)...rather religious differences among muslims are based on Islamic Beliefs/Concepts on the basis of Islamic History/Personalities.
without going into depths, Mr Amir Liaquat Hussain program is not Islam and not enough to regard him as Islamic Scholor and his tv programs never discuss the real issues faced by islamic ummah instead they are merely/mostly about tareekat. like "aap k masaayil aur un ka hal"
Essence of my writing and this post is that Amir Liquat is not a Islamic Scholor, he is just a practiced debator and completely a fraud person.
Reply Mr. SMarza, Maulana Modoodi OR Molana Yousuf Ludhiyanvi did not have any degree to become islamic scholor, because it is really not a criteria to have a degree to become a great scholor or scientist and there are many such examples, very much true.
However,
Had Maulana Modoodi OR Yousuf Ludhiyanvi bought a fake degree to bost themselves as Great Islamic Scholors then 1. They were regarded as people with fraud and fake minds/nature. However they never did so i mean they never did fake things in their lives as like Aamir Liaquat Hussain.
2. If it is proved that Amir Liaquat has bought such fake degrees to get himself regarded as a doctor/scholor of islam then according to your definition, if he was really experienced he never needed to do all such cheap and indecent things to fool people with fraud. Therefore, it also reveals his approach which is in contradiction to the criteria set by you Mr. SMarza.
3. His Islamic experience All his programs are based on the problems related to Tareeqat (Methodology) which is a branch of islamic studies. The actual problems faced by islamic ummah are not critical to Methodology (How to do How to offer Prayers, How much pay zakat etc)...rather religious differences among muslims are based on Islamic Beliefs/Concepts on the basis of Islamic History/Personalities.
without going into depths, Mr Amir Liaquat Hussain program is not Islam and not enough to regard him as Islamic Scholor and his tv programs never discuss the real issues faced by islamic ummah instead they are merely/mostly about tareekat. like "aap k masaayil aur un ka hal"
Essence of my writing and this post is that Amir Liquat is not a Islamic Scholor, he is just a practiced debator and completely a fraud person.