09-24-2010, 07:46 PM
<b>
Kisi aik ameer ko kamil jan kr or man kr ankhain bnd kr k uski itaat krna islam main mna hay. Administrative matters main tu uski baat full n final hay chahy wo hmain achi lgay ya nai, Relegious matter main uski baat final nahi hay agr wo Allah n Allah k Rasool SW ki baat kay mukhalif ho. Laikin one thing bear in mind k hmara hussn e zan ameer k baray main yehe hona chahyay k wo jan booj k ghalat ihkamat nahin day ga, but chances of his misunderstanding/miscommunication are always there (being human). As it is proved k Sahab Kiram RTA nay apas main jangain ki or aik dosray ko shaheed bhi kia the reason was Munafiqeen and miscommunication from muafiqeen. Laikin ham kis aik Sahabi ki side lay kr dosray ko ghalat nahi keh sktay coz hmari Oqat nahi hay k ham un Azeem Hastion k baray mainn faisla dain, laikin dono itraf main ghalfehmian thin.
</b>
i havent read whole post yet will surely read it and ask next question then
however have read till above bolded para
do agree with many things mentioned there
but have a question regarding the only thing i dont agree with
fana fee Allah k liyeah
fana fee Rasool hona lazmi hay
jiss k liyeah fana fee peer hona lazmi hay
so what u say about this?
Kisi aik ameer ko kamil jan kr or man kr ankhain bnd kr k uski itaat krna islam main mna hay. Administrative matters main tu uski baat full n final hay chahy wo hmain achi lgay ya nai, Relegious matter main uski baat final nahi hay agr wo Allah n Allah k Rasool SW ki baat kay mukhalif ho. Laikin one thing bear in mind k hmara hussn e zan ameer k baray main yehe hona chahyay k wo jan booj k ghalat ihkamat nahin day ga, but chances of his misunderstanding/miscommunication are always there (being human). As it is proved k Sahab Kiram RTA nay apas main jangain ki or aik dosray ko shaheed bhi kia the reason was Munafiqeen and miscommunication from muafiqeen. Laikin ham kis aik Sahabi ki side lay kr dosray ko ghalat nahi keh sktay coz hmari Oqat nahi hay k ham un Azeem Hastion k baray mainn faisla dain, laikin dono itraf main ghalfehmian thin.
</b>
i havent read whole post yet will surely read it and ask next question then
however have read till above bolded para
do agree with many things mentioned there
but have a question regarding the only thing i dont agree with
fana fee Allah k liyeah
fana fee Rasool hona lazmi hay
jiss k liyeah fana fee peer hona lazmi hay
so what u say about this?
