02-09-2011, 06:11 PM
<blockquote id="quote"><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, san" id="quote">quote<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"><i>Originally posted by LapTop</i>
<br />Faisal bhai,
ik bat samajh nahi aai, agar withholding agent Advance payment kary ga, chahy 2 ya 3 sal ki, to us k pass kya jawaz ho ga k us nay pory amount par tax withhold kyon nahi kiya?
<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"></font id="quote"></blockquote id="quote">
Dear Laptop,
A professional consultant, like you, should at least consider the query of the querier properly as to what has been asked by the querier, before replying.
Please read the query again i.e. "Is rent received in advance for more than one tax year taxable in entirety in the year when received? Give proper reason and also mention the relevant section".
It is quite clear that Muhammad Rehman wants to know from the recipient's point of view and even then you are replying (in your both replies) with regard to payer/withholding agent's point of view. Muhammad Rehman has no concern (in this query) as to which treatments should be followed by tenant / withholding agent. Had he asked any other thing then my reply would have been accordingly.
Furthermore, the query which you have asked me, is entirely another issue, i will surely reply your query if such need is arisen.
Keep up the good work, which you do.
Best Regards,
Faisal.
<br />Faisal bhai,
ik bat samajh nahi aai, agar withholding agent Advance payment kary ga, chahy 2 ya 3 sal ki, to us k pass kya jawaz ho ga k us nay pory amount par tax withhold kyon nahi kiya?
<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"></font id="quote"></blockquote id="quote">
Dear Laptop,
A professional consultant, like you, should at least consider the query of the querier properly as to what has been asked by the querier, before replying.
Please read the query again i.e. "Is rent received in advance for more than one tax year taxable in entirety in the year when received? Give proper reason and also mention the relevant section".
It is quite clear that Muhammad Rehman wants to know from the recipient's point of view and even then you are replying (in your both replies) with regard to payer/withholding agent's point of view. Muhammad Rehman has no concern (in this query) as to which treatments should be followed by tenant / withholding agent. Had he asked any other thing then my reply would have been accordingly.
Furthermore, the query which you have asked me, is entirely another issue, i will surely reply your query if such need is arisen.
Keep up the good work, which you do.
Best Regards,
Faisal.
