03-11-2009, 02:49 PM
Dear Tracen, the sufferings of others is always a news for us unless we ourselves become a news. You might remember 3/4 years back a WAPDA retired officer committed suiside by jumping from 4th floor of a WAPDA office from which office he got retired. The story, as I remember, was that it was now about a year his pension papers were not ready. He was frequently visiting this pension office where earlier he himself was working and his now ex-colleauges were delaying finalising his pension papers. In frustration he jumped from the building. If my memories are not misguiding me in this age he had some medicines in his hand as being a retired he was sick. The facts were he tasted the same medicine which he was administering while sitting on the seat to other pensioners.
My father is a retired clerk of 80 years. 300 bogus units is a too big amount. Yes mistakes do happen but when those are mistakes. Please put yourself into my shoes and then feel the pain I have - this is what Honourable Mr. Justice Sardar Iqbal once stated. This is not the first month. For the last 4 months similar excessive bills without taking any meter reading are coming.
And this is not a mistake this is then deliberate a policy under which to pull out from subscribers as much as possible through different techniques like in advance.
This is an accounting forum though the Administrator has very kindly clarified this portion is for any topic community related. Just take the current 300 excessive unused units onlyl. Leave the units for the last three months. On these 300 units the KESC has not merely charged excess energy charges but many other things like tax - one withholding tax. You are aware being a member of accountancy forum that in case you get a profit of Rs. 200 from your bank, Rs. 20/- is deducted by the Bank towards withholding tax and to get it refunded you need to file an income tax return, attach photo copies of dozens and dozens of papers costing you not less than Rs. 100, a few dozen trips to the income tax department, after lot of visit one day you might get a cheque of Rs. 20/- as refund on encashment of which your bank will deduct Rs. 80/- as clerance charges from your account.
So say undue withholding tax on these extra unused units I am paying is never going to come back even when KESC will correct the mistake because withholding tax one having deducted and forwarded to income tax Department, the KESC can not get it back to revert the entry.
My dear this is the reason I say it Haram because it is consistently going on under some unwritten policy. I am sure you are not a resident of Karachi otherwise your comment would not had been this.
My father is a retired clerk of 80 years. 300 bogus units is a too big amount. Yes mistakes do happen but when those are mistakes. Please put yourself into my shoes and then feel the pain I have - this is what Honourable Mr. Justice Sardar Iqbal once stated. This is not the first month. For the last 4 months similar excessive bills without taking any meter reading are coming.
And this is not a mistake this is then deliberate a policy under which to pull out from subscribers as much as possible through different techniques like in advance.
This is an accounting forum though the Administrator has very kindly clarified this portion is for any topic community related. Just take the current 300 excessive unused units onlyl. Leave the units for the last three months. On these 300 units the KESC has not merely charged excess energy charges but many other things like tax - one withholding tax. You are aware being a member of accountancy forum that in case you get a profit of Rs. 200 from your bank, Rs. 20/- is deducted by the Bank towards withholding tax and to get it refunded you need to file an income tax return, attach photo copies of dozens and dozens of papers costing you not less than Rs. 100, a few dozen trips to the income tax department, after lot of visit one day you might get a cheque of Rs. 20/- as refund on encashment of which your bank will deduct Rs. 80/- as clerance charges from your account.
So say undue withholding tax on these extra unused units I am paying is never going to come back even when KESC will correct the mistake because withholding tax one having deducted and forwarded to income tax Department, the KESC can not get it back to revert the entry.
My dear this is the reason I say it Haram because it is consistently going on under some unwritten policy. I am sure you are not a resident of Karachi otherwise your comment would not had been this.



