11-11-2004, 05:39 PM
Well Pracs,
Interesting issue raised by you,
dont u think it is similar to the following case
Suppose i have earned Rs.500,000/- from halal sources and Rs.500,000/- from a bank robbery / cheating / etc...
now i m going to invest that 1 mn. to establish a charitable organization. That organization will be based on haram income and then how can the activities of that organization be halal.... although that organization is in the favor of society.
Now coming to the further contributions by the general public and earning income from those contributions..... Will that be halal???
If we say to the extent of amount of robbery it is haram and rest is halal, then who is going to measure if the organization earns the income of Rs.100,000/- ???? That how much portion is halal and haram.
It is very debatable issue.
SMR
Interesting issue raised by you,
dont u think it is similar to the following case
Suppose i have earned Rs.500,000/- from halal sources and Rs.500,000/- from a bank robbery / cheating / etc...
now i m going to invest that 1 mn. to establish a charitable organization. That organization will be based on haram income and then how can the activities of that organization be halal.... although that organization is in the favor of society.
Now coming to the further contributions by the general public and earning income from those contributions..... Will that be halal???
If we say to the extent of amount of robbery it is haram and rest is halal, then who is going to measure if the organization earns the income of Rs.100,000/- ???? That how much portion is halal and haram.
It is very debatable issue.
SMR
