Accountancy Forum
  • Accountancy
  • Forum Home
  • Members
  • Team
  • Help
  • Search
  • Register
  • Login
  • Home
  • Members
  • Help
  • Search
Accountancy Forum The Profession Firms v
« Previous 1 … 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 Next »
importance of reference in Big Three

 
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
importance of reference in Big Three
bilal azhar
Offline

Member

Posts: 239
Threads: 28
Joined: Nov 2004
Reputation: 0
#46
06-09-2005, 05:18 AM
Salmanj,firstly tell me why u are registring urself with icap when u think that acca is better than CA qualified,and has a far better scope both in pakistan and internationally.IF a person is going from a superior thing to an inferior,then he must be out of his senses(as u are).

Yes,because i am doing ca thats why i thing that ca is better than acca,and i am proud of being a student of ca.Not many acca students can say this( this is my personal experience).i know four or five people around me,including one of my cousin,whoms main aim is to do ca but they are doing acca simply to get an exemption from ca inter.they think that acca is easier to pass than ca inter,and they can save their time through this way.

Salmanj,this is a general perception in ca that icap dont pass the exempted students very easily.

it is now confirmed that u have a jealousy against ca.

ur words are in contradiction with ur actions.but i dont blame u,because u are a pakistani.

i heard somewhere that u can become an acca even after training for 3 years in a library.
now if u are comparing an acca librarian with a ca student having spent four hard years in a firm,then who is clown?you or me?(definitely u).

why employers prefer ca qualified over acca in pakistan.Tell me?

u can pass acca by studying just from one prescribed book.in ca,this is not the case. u has a fifty percent choice in ur paper,in ca there is no choice. our progression rules are far more tougher than u.U dont have any knowledge of local laws,just read the course of corporate law of module E,and ur eyes will be opened. in pakistan accounts have to be audited in compliance with companies ordinance 1984,u dont know ABC of company ordinance 1984.u have to study 12-13 subjects to clear acca,we had to pass over 21 papers which means ca covers far more subjects and areas than u.

why the required qualification for a Finance manager or an account manager in the local newspaper advertisements is CA qualified,ca inter,or even icma and not acca.

Lastly,have u thought why the manager at the yousuf adil lied with u.if u think deep down,u will find the answer,and i think the answer will not be too pleasing.

i already had too many enemies on this forum due to the phrase that "ca is better than acca". i guess their number will increase now,thats why i did not want to start this debate onceagain. i said it all what i think.i dont want to continue this topic anyfurther.so it doesnt matter to me whether u reply or not,because this is my last post on the topic ca v/s acca.

i dont see anything wrong in having a discussion like this,but when u people start personal attacks then i know things are getting very hot over there(at ur desk).


bilal
mzosama
Offline

Junior Member

Posts: 14
Threads: 0
Joined: Jan 2004
Reputation: 0
#47
06-09-2005, 05:38 AM
today i gave interview in kpmg...the first question they asked me...whats ur reference....?
i know guyz who passed matriculation and intermediate by getting 80% plus marks, clear ca inter in first attempt but still unable to get articles in big 4..simply because they dont have reference.

Usama Zulfiqar
www.mzosama.cjb.net
mzosama
Offline

Junior Member

Posts: 14
Threads: 0
Joined: Jan 2004
Reputation: 0
#48
06-09-2005, 06:12 AM
chill guyz...ACCA and CA are both good qualifications....simply if u want to earn prestigious status in pakistan then CA is must for it..else there is no harm in doing ACCA..it opens the door for the jobs in foreign countries....I think even if ICAEW comes in pakistan like ACCA then again CA will be preferred over ICAEW...exemptions will be finished...Local laws are always superior than internation laws and this fact is known everywhere...



Usama Zulfiqar
www.webcontra.com
www.mzosama.cjb.net
Nauman
Offline

Member

Posts: 240
Threads: 11
Joined: Dec 2004
Reputation: 0
#49
06-16-2005, 01:25 AM
Salmanj you gotto be kidding saying that ACCA is better then CA then you tell Bilal Azhar that not to blame you if he is not qualified enough to do ACCA, if you havent noticed 90 percent of students who cannot pass module A and B go on starting ACCA and pass the exams there easily, same goes for CA students who cannot complete CA and thus leave it and complete ACCA hell it doesnt even have enough value in England they prefer ICAEW over ACCA. ACCA is nothing more than a diploma.

Regards
Nauman-ul-Haq
Desert Sleet
Offline

Senior Member

Posts: 339
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2005
Reputation: 0
#50
06-18-2005, 05:01 AM
<blockquote id="quote"><font size="1" face="Verdana, Tahoma, Arial" id="quote">quote<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"><i>Originally posted by Nauman</i>
<br />Salmanj you gotto be kidding saying that ACCA is better then CA then you tell Bilal Azhar that not to blame you if he is not qualified enough to do ACCA, if you havent noticed 90 percent of students who cannot pass module A and B go on starting ACCA and pass the exams there easily, same goes for CA students who cannot complete CA and thus leave it and complete ACCA hell it doesnt even have enough value in England they prefer ICAEW over ACCA. ACCA is nothing more than a diploma.

Regards
Nauman-ul-Haq
<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"></font id="quote"></blockquote id="quote">hmm where to begin, forgive me however if I keep it short but get your facts straight before posting.. you make so many mistakes and mistatements that you have virtually no credibility.


1. You generalised hundreds of ACCA students.

2. The only value this thread had was to annoy people.

3. It has no value for debate.

4. It was rude to any ACCA who may decide to post here.

Is that enough?



__________________
<blockquote id="quote"><font size="1" face="Verdana, Tahoma, Arial" id="quote">quote<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"><b>The Only True Wisdom Is In Knowing You Know Nothing </b> <hr height="1" noshade id="quote"></font id="quote"></blockquote id="quote">
Ali Akbar
Offline

Senior Member

Posts: 429
Threads: 21
Joined: Oct 2004
Reputation: 0
#51
06-19-2005, 04:41 AM
AoA

I agree with u Bilal. I have seen two guyz in my college, who were completing their articles as being a librarian!! this is ACCA. Mr Deser Sleet this is not generalization ok. this is ur ACCA leniency. Moerover I have seen a distinction holder in ACCA completing his articles as being a teacher!! Again this is ACCA.

Thats why I say that ICAPis the bestin this regard.
Mr. Whappaaaa
Offline

Member

Posts: 206
Threads: 15
Joined: Sep 2004
Reputation: 0
#52
06-19-2005, 05:52 AM
<blockquote id="quote"><font size="1" face="Verdana, Tahoma, Arial" id="quote">quote<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"><i>Originally posted by Ali Akbar</i>
<br />AoA

I agree with u Bilal. I have seen two guyz in my college, who were completing their articles as being a librarian!! this is ACCA. Mr Deser Sleet this is not generalization ok. this is ur ACCA leniency. Moerover I have seen a distinction holder in ACCA completing his articles as being a teacher!! Again this is ACCA.

Thats why I say that ICAPis the bestin this regard.
<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"></font id="quote"></blockquote id="quote">

ALI AKBAR,

First of all, I dont want to commence another debate regarding ACCA vs CA... ALI, you have to confess that ACCA's are also competitively far good enough position in pakistan. I dont know why you are refering & spamming ACCA's articleship as a librarian.Ali, Every one has its own individual perspective. Beleive, ACCA is tough, specially part three papers. I, myself will be doing ACCA core attempt & realy it is tough & the passing criteria of CORE papers is also tough.Some of my colleagues has given the core papers of ACCA & now they have accepted that there is much difficult to pass papers of ACCA at final stage. I like to say that see the past examination CORE papers( part three) & compare it with module A to D, then respond me with conclusion. As I have said earlier that in Pakistan, there is no doubt that ICAP's CA is best but again i want to say that ACCA's are also exist in pakistan.

As far as Articleship is concerned, beleive, A.F.Ferguson & Co.(Karachi) are going to conduct Presentation in our College, because they need ACCA finalists & Affiliates. They Want to hire ACCA's. Earnst & Young has also conducted the Seminar here in Karachi to get ACCA's for three yrs relevent experience. KPMG is also preferring ACCA affiliates here but being as a Librarian I dont know what the story behind this situation. Lets tel me that are they ACCA qualified ? Arwe they Male or Female? ( mostly Female dont prefer practical training in a FIRM). One of my friend who is just qualified ACCA, now doing his Article in A.F.Ferguson & Co. Again i said Its All depends on ACCA student.





ASIF ALI
Azeem Shah Khan
Offline

Senior Member

Posts: 662
Threads: 17
Joined: Jun 2004
Reputation: 0
#53
06-19-2005, 06:01 AM
What a pitty, a discussion on this topic without my participation.
[)] For the good of many Pro-CAs I have no intention to start en endless debate here. All I can suggest them to stop this non-sense for good, this is not good for the profession as whole.

Salman's post was a good one. Desert Sleet's points were also valid.

Hoping to see positive response from fellow CAs.

Kind regards

"You don't get to choose how you're going to die. Or when. You can only decide how you're going to live. Now."
Pracs
Offline

Posting Freak

Posts: 1,498
Threads: 27
Joined: Nov 2002
Reputation: 0
#54
06-19-2005, 06:44 AM
Let's not get into the articles and librarian and all, pre ACCA too,..i.e CA students.. I know many people who used to be enrolled on to Accountancy firms registers and did book articles. that is full time study or a job or whatever. What did we call them.. Ghost articles, Silent articles.. whatever.. its quite pointless you know..
salmanj
Offline

Junior Member

Posts: 6
Threads: 1
Joined: May 2005
Reputation: 0
#55
06-21-2005, 03:58 AM
Here we go again. I think the time is right for me to butt in with my two cents once again. These guys have provoked me just right.

I'll start with Nauman. First of all, let me thank you for being so ignorant, makes my job easier. I never said Bilal wasnt qualified enough to do ACCA, though come to think of it, he probably isnt. What I said was its better to do ACCA first, and then register to ICAP for CA, since the articles requirement is less, you get an additional degree and modules E and F are considerably easier to pass since you are already familiar with the syllabus. And I suggested Bilal's prejudice against ACCA was based on the fact that he chose the wrong route.

Secondly, I dont know where you people come up with these statistics. 90% of people start ACCA after failing CA? I have done ACCA and I have come across alot of senior/junior ACCA students over the years. I have not come across a single person who started ACCA after failing module A or B. So I dont believe a single word you are saying, and I am sure none of the ACCA students will believe you as well. Although, if somebody did start ACCA after initially starting CA, maybe its because he figured ACCA was better.

What would an ACCA v/s CA arguement be without a pro-CA claiming CA is tougher. Thats like your slogan isnt it? Well just because a degree is tougher doesnt necessarily mean its better to begin with. I think the syllabus content and degree demand decide which degree is better.

I have reviewed your syllabus, and frankly its not that tough. Its very similar to the ACCA syllabus, and since I already explained how your syllabus was outdated on a few occasions, ACCA wins in that department hands down. Agreed?

The demand for ACCA in Pakistan is pretty sufficient in its own right, I have seen affiliates being appointed as internal auditors in a few companies without any articles. ACCA has earned alot of respect and its getting more recognition day by day. But CA Pakistan is the big dog in this pound, no arguements there. Still, since ACCA is recognised in alot of other countries, it covers a greater area which means its demand is more. You are probably stil not convinced so let me elaborate.

You say even in England they prefer ICAEW over ACCA. First of all you are perfectly eligible for an Executive post over there after ACCA at a decent salary. Secondly, if you go there and decide to do ICAEW you are awarded exemptions, and this is true for alot of other countries. You are given exemptions from the local CA of those countries, ICAP is another example. How many exemptions do you think you will get if you go there after doing CA Pakistan? Since we are on the subject, after ACCA you are eligible for exemptions in CIMA as well. There might be more degrees, I'm not sure. None of this is true for CA Pakistan.

Coming back to what I said earlier, just because CA is tougher to pass doesnt warrant it being better. Everyone knows that ICAP passes students on a quota basis and thats the only reason you people keep failing, so dont get me started there. I think its about time you guys stopped whinning like a couple of middle aged divorced women and studied a little harder. Dont keep saying ACCA is easier because you cant think of anything else. You call it being easy, I call it fair marking.

Ali Akbar, you are right. ACCA does allow the affiliates to teach, for a maximum of one year, during the 3 year professional training required by the degree. I dont see any harm in that. Teaching is a profession as well, and if ACCA is flexible enough to include it, why are you losing sleep over it? But the librarian story is something I dont buy.

Bilal Azher. You make so little sense, I'm not sure how to reply to you. I think I have said enough, though I'd appreciate it if you could put away your bong for a second and elaborate on something you wrote.

"ur words are in contradiction with ur actions.but i dont blame u,because u are a pakistani"

Whats that all about? I'm completely lost. Let me end this with a little advice. You and your friends should gracefully admit that you have been outdone, and you have lost this arguement. Its no big deal, and I am not your enemy like you said. (That was hilarious by the way). Stop embarrassing yourself and your fellow CAs. You are making them look bad, really. It doesnt matter what you keep telling yourself, ACCA is here to stay whether you like it or not.

Salman Javed Hashmi
Azeem Shah Khan
Offline

Senior Member

Posts: 662
Threads: 17
Joined: Jun 2004
Reputation: 0
#56
06-21-2005, 05:54 AM
I am beginning to enjoy the action - reminding some old memories.

Salman There are some people on board who knowingly act as nuts so whats the point wasting your time and energy explaining what is right and what is wrong.

Kind regards




"You don't get to choose how you're going to die. Or when. You can only decide how you're going to live. Now."
bilal azhar
Offline

Member

Posts: 239
Threads: 28
Joined: Nov 2004
Reputation: 0
#57
06-21-2005, 06:04 AM
SAlmanj,sixth line of ur last reply has really made me happy.i have now realized that i had really made u angry.
Salmanj,
*ACCA is a very good degree.
*it has a great demand outside the pakistan.
*its syllubus is very conceptual.
*if u want to go abroad then do acca.

but but but...........................

IT is not equivalent to even ca inter in pakistan.If u are living in pakistan,then talk about our local degrees,dont talk about international degrees.

I think we all pakistanis should be proud of the fact that ca qualifieds from pakistan are recognised all through the world.There are not too many pakistani degrees that these goras accept in their countries.

Acca may have a good market abroad,but in pakistan it is not equal to ca inter.and i am very happy that this international degree(acca) has failed to degrade our local(ca) degree.

And by the way who made u refree by saying that we have lost the battle. i think u have lost ur senses and patience.




bilal
bilal azhar
Offline

Member

Posts: 239
Threads: 28
Joined: Nov 2004
Reputation: 0
#58
06-21-2005, 06:04 AM
SAlmanj,sixth line of ur last reply has really made me happy.i have now realized that i had really made u angry.
Salmanj,
*ACCA is a very good degree.
*it has a great demand outside the pakistan.
*its syllubus is very conceptual.
*if u want to go abroad then do acca.

but but but...........................

IT is not equivalent to even ca inter in pakistan.If u are living in pakistan,then talk about our local degrees,dont talk about international degrees.

I think we all pakistanis should be proud of the fact that ca qualifieds from pakistan are recognised all through the world.There are not too many pakistani degrees that these goras accept in their countries.

Acca may have a good market abroad,but in pakistan it is not equal to ca inter.and i am very happy that this international degree(acca) has failed to degrade our local(ca) degree.

And by the way who made u refree by saying that we have lost the battle. i think u have lost ur senses and patience.




bilal
Pracs
Offline

Posting Freak

Posts: 1,498
Threads: 27
Joined: Nov 2002
Reputation: 0
#59
06-21-2005, 06:05 AM
SalmanJ, no matter what you say,.. people in the other camp are just not going to listen to reason, logic or any thing on those civilised lines. We have had this discussion earlier on different threads with different people, but I haven't seen any converts. People stay with their own ''mindset'' and that my friend is our national trait as well. We as a nation do not like to change for the better, that is why we go out to the world ''ashamed'' of our existence but do nothing to ammend that or even think about it.

Life does teach you a lot of things, and I guess people learn better when they step into ''practical life''. If degrees/qualifications alone determined your success in career, every CA would be minting money, that is not the case.. your qualification is just one of the factors.
mzosama
Offline

Junior Member

Posts: 14
Threads: 0
Joined: Jan 2004
Reputation: 0
#60
06-25-2005, 11:12 PM
Salaam,
Yes its true that local degree previals over the international degree. ACCA lags behind the Local TAX and LAW. Infact now ACCA has included Pakistani TAX variant in ACCA. Salmanj has many times emphasized over the ACCA and CA syllabus. The point is that ACCA includes much deeper and uptodate knowledge about the standards, cost accounting and strategic information management.
To pass all ACCA core papers in a row, one has to gain and understand the knowledge of all standards, and other stuff like APV (Advance Net Present Value), Beta (Used in calculating the risk of company which is used to calculate discount rate and the valuation of companies. CAPM) Foreign Currency (Forward Rate Agreement, Futures, SWAPS, Options, Swaptions) etc..these terms are not well knownn to CA inter students..These topics are tested in CA Mod E. So it is useless to compare ACCA with CA inter in repect of syllabus. (TAX and LAW excluded. ACCA have more knowledge than CA inter..

i think i have to give you the link of core question paper which was examined
http//www.accaglobal.com/students/professionalscheme/paper3_7/pastpapers/3-7_2004_dec_q.pdf

Just read out the questions and then tell me whether CA inter student understand these type of questions...

Saying that ACCA is not equal to CA inter is useless..

Allah Hafiz.

Usama Zulfiqar
www.webcontra.com
www.mzosama.cjb.net
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »

Users browsing this thread:

Pages (6): « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next »


  • View a Printable Version
  • Subscribe to this thread
Forum Jump:

© 2002-2024 Accountancy. Copyrights of all content on this web site are owned by Accountancy except where indicated in source or copyright statements. Accountancy must be contacted for permission to copy or redistribute any material published on this website.

Linear Mode
Threaded Mode